This is probably the toughest to pick so far. Virtually came down to a final pick of three. Initially it seemed relatively straight forward but the information on John 'Cracker' McDonald has shown that if anything this entire process has unearthed some 'gems'.
Percy Mason's book published in 1985, "Professional Athletics in Australia" whilst is very good in a lot of ways was light on for detail in many areas, particularly in respect to non Victorian material, and the case of John McDonald highlights that. McDonald doesn't get one mention in the book even though he was probably the fastest 440 yards runner of his time, quite probably in Australia - amateur or pro.
It's for this reason we are down to three athletes -
John McDonald
Bill McManus
Robert Ballard
Whilst extremely diverse in terms of achievements, it is diffucult to line the three of them up.
John McDonald
We've already read about Cracker McDonald in other posts - he was basically the gun quarter miler in the late 60's and early 70's running and winning from scratch in the NSWAL and QAL. There is one unconfirmed report he may have run 46.1 off scratch for 400m at a NSW or QLD meet. Certainly his 46.7 emulating Herb McKenley was by all acounts a brilliant performance.
Bill McManus
Born at Muttama in 1869, Bill McManus started his running career at the age of 14. During the next 35 years of competition, McManus raced in 400 events for 116 wins, 72 seconds and 30 thirds. At his best, McManus was considered the best all round athlete in the world.
A long striding runner, he was extremely fit, capable of winning four events in a day and nine events in nine days over various distances. His best distance was the 440 yards.
McManus won the 440 yards at Stawell in 1899 off the back mark of 12 yards and returned in 1900 to win the 440 again off 6 yards. He was 2nd in the 1900 220 yards off 3 yards. In 1901 and 1902 McManus ran 2nd off 6 yards in the 440 yards.
He won the 100 yards professional title in Sydney in 1901.
He won over 20 440 yard races off scratch:
May 1900, Gympie, QLD
Dec 1901, Great Western VIC
Mar 1902, Hamilton VIC
Dec 1903, Talbot VIC
Jan 1904, Maryborough VIC
1904, Clunes, VIC
1904, Hamilton, VIC
1904, Ballarat, VIC
1904, Garden
1904, Ravenswood, VIC
1906, Hamilton, VIC
1907, Clunes, VIC
1907, Wal Wal, VIC
1908, Wal Wal, VIC
1908, Willaura
1908, Maryborough QLD
1908, Mt Morgan QLD
1908, Rockhampton QLD
1908, Sydney NSW
1909, Rainbow VIC
McManus adopted Stawell as his home town and relished in the ideal training conditions available at the time.
In the 1908 half mile at Stawell, McManus beat world champion Jack Donaldson and four weeks later won again over 440 yards at Maryborough in Queensland.
Robert Ballard
Ballard was the first ‘reinstated’ professional athlete to compete at an Olympic Games when he ran in the 4 x 400m relay at the 1988 Seoul Olympics.
Through the 80’s and 90’s, Ballard became the most accomplished pro runner from 120m to 400m in the sport, winning several races off tight handicap including three consecutive backmarker races at Stawell between 1987 and 1989.
Ballard ran 2nd on his Stawell debut in the Bill Howard 100m. In 1986 he was favourite when runner up to Glen Chapman in the Stawell Gift. He made two more Stawell Gift finals finishing 3rd in 1997 and 4th in 1998.
Ballard was 3rd in the Australian 400m title and made three Australian national finals going well inside 47s each time.
Ballard’s life time 400m PB of 46.19 was run in an Olympic warm up meet at Seoul in September 1988.
So the choice comes down to:
an Aust pro record holder who was arguably the best quarter miler in the country, amateur or pro;
the best quarter miler for the first 10 years of the century and has the Stawell 400m named after him;
and the first to make an Olympic team and with 46.19, probably the fastest pro running 400m runner for the first 90 years of the century.
Tough decision - to be announced after further consideration.